Annie Oakley

Gail Davis

Annie Oakley

Jimmy Hawkins

Tagg Oakley

Brad Johnson

Deputy Sheriff Lofty Craig, Deputy Sherriff Lofty Craig

Edward Earle

Priest

John Parrish

Hank Thompson

Damian O'Flynn

Frank Griffin

Sam Flint

Cy Crawford, Wilson, Howard Bishop, Banker Willis, Doctor, Doc Seymour, Digger Bagley, Banker Oliver

Marshall Reed

Al - Hotel Desk Clerk (uncredited), Hired Killer

Al Bridge

Walt Stone, Pop Wade

Darryl Hickman

Chet Sterling

John Eldredge

Frank Sterling

Clayton Moore

Henchman

Don C. Harvey

Henchman Cody Barnes, Outlaw Leader Lacey, Dallas Carson, Dave Murdock - Henchman

Melinda Casey

Penny

Fess Parker

Tom Conrad - Newspaper Publisher, Len Clinton - The Texas Sandman

Gene Reynolds

Steve Bailey

Larry Chance

Con Morley, Rick Yancy

Selmer Jackson

John Cromby - Rancher

Charles Williams

Fred

Ralph Sanford

Pete the Drunk

Richard Reeves

Dixie, Tomahawk Tommy, Brady, Billy Yancey

Lee Van Cleef

Tim Brennan, Amos Belcher

Ron Hagerthy

Chuck Hutchins aka Waco Kid, Billy Stryker

Bob Woodward

Amos Biddle (uncredited), Henchman Ed Reed, Stagecoach Driver, Vic, Westerner, Mr. Thornwald, Outlaw Conway, Pete - Stagecoach Driver, Kramer - Mine Manager, Posse Rider (uncredited), Woody (uncredited), Stagecoach Driver (uncredited), Henchman, Stage Agent (uncredited), Posse Member, Stableman (uncredited), Stage Guard Dave (uncredited), Stage Driver (uncredited), Henchman Al Murdock, Tobacco Buyer (uncredited), Stage Driver Jim, Andy, Townsman, Henchman Bart, Saloon Henchman (uncredited)

Tom Steele

Bob Fitzsimmons

John George

Worker at Show (uncredited)

Judy Nugent

Donna Bishop

John Doucette

Duke Bailey, Hugo Barrett

Keith Richards

Bob Brennan, Dan Bradshaw, Mandel, Adam Scott, Duke Marteen, D.K. Rodney

Paul E. Burns

Station Agent Phil (uncredited), Justice of the Peace, Paul Denain, Telegrapher, Clem Lacey, Station Agent Jim

Harry Harvey

Storekeeper Cody, Sergeant O'Hara, Mayor Pearlson

Denver Pyle

Dr. Barnes, Tom Malloy

Stanley Andrews

Snowy Kringle, George Lacy, Clay Griffin, Pop Hackett

Richard Alexander

George Todd

George J. Lewis

Chief Angry Owl, Henchman Frenchy, Morgan - Henchman, Hopi Bill

Eve Brent

Clara Bickel

Lane Bradford

Luke Dallas

Robert Easton

Abner Harkey

Terry Frost

Logan, Henchman, Wagon driver Lou, Henchman Gibbs

Ken Osmond

Scotty

Raymond Hatton

Scissorbill Childers, Tim Lafferty

Robert "Buzz" Henry

Cal Blane

L.Q. Jones

Ned Blane

Tom London

Buckhorn - Diablo Stage Manager, Pop Leeds, Ranch Hand

Walter Reed

Ben Cobey, Jim Miller, Arthur Berkeley, Henry Hayden

Frank J. Scannell

Mack Darrell

George Pembroke

Sills - the Welshman