Mystery Island hosts contest winners vying to solve a fake murder for a grand prize, but the event goes awry when an employee is murdered, and secrets are uncovered.
Not for warmth, laughs or comfort.
Pick a department, or search for a name or a job (“editor”, “stunt”).
You are here: Mystery Island: Winner Takes AllPoint to compare, tap or drag to moveHold to compare, tap or drag to move
You are herePreview
vscompared with Mystery Island: Winner Takes All
Mystery Island: Winner Takes All2025
Point at a poster to compare itHold a poster to compare it
A chip fills to its level. Tap a full one for titles without that trait, a low one for titles with it.
Open a page:Paranoid (2016)The Body (2012)Evaru (2019)Murder Mubarak (2024)The Keeper of Lost Causes (2013)Black Coal, Thin Ice (2014)House of Games (1987)Ittefaq (2017)A Private Life (2025)Raat Akeli Hai (2020)The Breakthrough (2025)HIT: The First Case (2020)The Silent Hour (2024)With a Friend Like Harry... (2000)Stuck (2007)Shimmer Lake (2017)11:14 (2004)Dhuruvangal Pathinaaru (2016)Kahaani (2012)Blow the Man Down (2019)You've Got Murder (2019)The Last of Sheila (1973)Big Bad Wolves (2013)Thadam (2019)Jaane Jaan (2023)Ripley's Game (2002)Butterfly on a Wheel (2007)Anweshippin Kandethum (2024)Criminal (2004)Headhunters (2011)Black Widow (1987)V (2020)Loft (2008)The Night of the 12th (2022)Confession of Murder (2012)Roadgames (1981)TransSiberian (2008)Narrow Margin (1990)Tell No One (2006)The Other Me (2017)Nightwatch (1994)Crazxy (2025)Haseen Dillruba (2021)The Good Thief (2003)The Lookout (2007)No Mercy (2010)Anjaam Pathiraa (2020)Dept. Q (2025)Small Town Crime (2018)Narc (2002)Colors of Evil: Red (2024)Chance (2016)Victoria (2015)At the End of the Tunnel (2016)Hard Candy (2006)A Hard Day (2014)Rekhachithram (2025)Le Doulos (1962)Confidence (2003)The Last Deadly Mission (2008)Death Note: L Change the WorLd (2008)The Disappearance of Alice Creed (2009)The Snow Girl (2023)Breach (2007)
Mystery Island2023
Mystery Island: Winner Takes All2025 · You're here
Mystery Island: Play for Keeps2025
Mystery Island: House Rules2025
GoodWatch score 75
GoodWatch score 79
GoodWatch score 80
GoodWatch score 74
GoodWatch score 74
GoodWatch score 84
GoodWatch score 68
GoodWatch score 73March 13, 2025 · 1 h 24 min · PG
5 questions, like "Where can I stream Mystery Island: Winner Takes All?"
Quick answers from GoodWatch data.
In the United States, Mystery Island: Winner Takes All streams on Philo, Hallmark+, and Hallmark TV, and it is free with ads on Hoopla. You can rent or buy it from Apple TV Store and Fandango At Home. It also streams in 3 other countries.
Opinions are mixed, with a GoodWatch score of 61 (IMDb 5.8).
Yes: it's movie 2 of 4 in its series, after Mystery Island (2023) and before Mystery Island: Play for Keeps (2025).
Not for young kids: it's rated PG in the United States for violence, and the viewing guide lists it for teens and adults.
Mostly plot-driven: intrigue (9 of 10) and mystery (9 of 10) carry it more than its characters do.
5.8
