Name: My Amish Double Life
Genre: Thriller
Released: 2025-02-22
Duration: 1 h 28 min
Cast: Lexi Minetree, Lesa Wilson, Rachel Coopes, Ty Trumbo, Nick Clark

Where to watch

Set your services

Fingerprint

Not for warmth, laughs or comfort.

Movies with

Story

By day Emma is a good Amish girl, but by night she sneaks out with her Amish friend, Rebecca, and together they lead a double life, going to clubs, flirting with boys, and falling in love in the forbidden “English” world. When Emma accidentally witnesses a murder while out, her life and community is thrown into peril.

Feels like

Amish Thriller
Double Life
Forbidden Romance
Witness to Murder
Community Peril
High Tension
Crime
Psychological

Cast

8 of 8

Crew

Directed by: Cooper Harrington
Written by: Ken Sanders, John J. Tierney, Bryan Dick
Produced by: Ken Sanders
Music by: Steve Gurevitch

Everyone

Pick a department, or search for a name or a job (“editor”, “stunt”).

Titles like My Amish Double Life

nearer = more alike

8

You are here: My Amish Double Life

Point to compare, tap or drag to moveHold to compare, tap or drag to move

You are herePreview

vscompared with My Amish Double Life

My Amish Double Life2025

Point at a poster to compare itHold a poster to compare it

This pageTap it to move here

A chip fills to its level. Tap a full one for titles without that trait, a low one for titles with it.

Open a page:Prospect (2018)Snabba Cash (2021)Relay (2025)Coolie (2025)Dollhouse (2009)Dark Angel (2000)Orphan Black (2013)Kimi (2022)Cyberpunk: Edgerunners (2022)Identity (2025)Ascension (2014)Torchwood (2006)Time Lapse (2014)Crazxy (2025)Snowpiercer (2020)If Wishes Could Kill (2026)Terror in Resonance (2014)Table No. 21 (2013)The Beauty (2026)Oh, Hi! (2025)Looper (2012)Upgrade (2018)Continuum (2012)24 (2016)The Fury (1978)The Future Diary (2011)Travelers (2016)Monsters (2010)Limitless (2011)Justice League: Doom (2012)The Machine (2013)Humans (2015)Better Than Us (2018)Officer on Duty (2025)Steve (2025)Cyber Vaar (2022)The Imperfects (2022)Psycho-Pass (2012)Altered Carbon (2018)The Artifice Girl (2023)V Wars (2019)Daybreakers (2010)Level 16 (2018)Sense8 (2015)Roswell, New Mexico (2019)The Assessment (2025)Attack the Block (2011)Mantis (2025)Paradise (2025)Biohackers (2020)Colony (2016)See You Yesterday (2019)Agni (2024)Kaala Paani (2023)Hallow Road (2025)Brainstorm (1983)Yennai Arindhaal (2015)Beforeigners (2019)Defying Gravity (2009)I, Robot (2004)If I Had Legs I'd Kick You (2025)Sleight (2017)Hanna (2011)What Happened to Monday (2017)

More thriller movies

The Silence of the Lambs (1991)
GoodWatch score 89
Prisoners (2013)
GoodWatch score 79
Sicario (2015)
GoodWatch score 83
Cloverfield (2008)
GoodWatch score 70
The Bourne Supremacy (2004)
GoodWatch score 77
Inside Man (2006)
GoodWatch score 78
Fast Five (2011)
GoodWatch score 73
Red Dragon (2002)
GoodWatch score 68

Facts

February 22, 2025 · 1 h 28 min · Violence, Sexual Content, Strong Language

Released: February 22, 2025
Runtime: 1 h 28 min
Content: Violence, Sexual Content, Strong Language
Genres: Thriller
Original language: English
Made in: United States
Available in: 4 countries
Keywords: based on true story

Q&A

3 questions, like "Where can I stream My Amish Double Life?"

Questions about My Amish Double Life

Quick answers from GoodWatch data.

Where can I stream My Amish Double Life?

In the United States, My Amish Double Life streams on Lifetime and Lifetime Movie Club, and it is free with ads on Hoopla and Tubi TV. You can rent or buy it from Google Play Movies, YouTube, and Fandango At Home. It also streams in 3 other countries.

Is My Amish Double Life worth watching?

59

DecentGoodWatch score

Opinions are mixed, with a GoodWatch score of 59 (IMDb 5.4).

Is My Amish Double Life good for date night?

Date NightPartner WatchAdultsFriends NightSolo Watch

Yes: romance is 6 of 10, and the viewing guide lists it for date night.