Man Seeking Woman

Jay Baruchel

Josh Greenberg

Eric André

Mike Scaggs

Britt Lower

Liz Greenberg

Maya Erskine

Maggie

Katie Findlay

Lucy Parker

Minka Kelly

Whitney

Caroline Palmer

Sonya

Tomaso Sanelli

Nicky

Tim Heidecker

Bartender

Emily Hampshire

Krystal

Sarah Silverman

Josh's Right Hand (voice)

Sara Alicia Garcia

Sara

Maria Thayer

Maude Metzger

Anna Konkle

Kayla

Jon Daly

Daniel

Marc Evan Jackson

Judge

Chris Ratz

Johnny

Carly Jones

Amy

Matt Lucas

Igor

Josh Meyers

Frankenboyfriend

Natalie Krill

Katie

Alina Prijono

Alice

Millie Davis

Victoria

Megan Fedorchuk

Samantha

Sadie Munroe

Jane

Brittany Johnson

Lindsay

Scott Cavalheiro

Charlie

Maya Eshet

Unkluk'tu

Bruce Pirrie

Minister

Samuel Faraci

7 Year Old Josh

Linette Doherty

Customer #1

Desmond Campbell

Resistance Fighter

Peter Hewitt

Past Josh

Cecily Strong

CCN Reporter

Rachel Dratch

Methelda

Paul Nicholas Mason

Monk

Nicholas Fry

Peasant Boy

Makenna Lyn Beatty

Peasant Girl

Sarah Gadon

Kelly

Kalinka Pétrie

Morgan

Araya Mengesha

Jamal

Patrick Kwok-Choon

Spencer

Lukas Penar

Lumberjack

Brian Paul

The General

Liane Balaban

Claire

Lisa Codrington

Dr. Sheila Evans

Clyde Whitham

Middle Aged Man

Josh Robert Thompson

Condom

Clara Pasieka

Bored Girl

Helen King

Middle Aged Woman

Aaron Hammond

Kyle

Giancarlo Murano

The Ramone

Bill Lake

Police Captain

Samer Salem

Rookie Cop

Caitlin Pasquet

Kara

Robin Givens

Vicki Claus

Peter Giles

Santa

Dan Abramovici

Jimmie

Jesse Camacho

Pete Hoffman

Brittany Drisdelle

Alice Hoffman

Kyle Kass

Valeron

Christie Stewart

Albon

Thomas Duplessie

Borlon

Farhang Ghajar

Nate

Kevin McDonald

Chainsaw

Callum Keith Rennie

McQuaid

Martin Roach

Ramirez

Vitali Makarov

Dr. Orlof

Michael Patrick O'Brien

Date Wrangler

Rosa Salazar

Rosa / Bosa, Rosa

Carrie-Anne Moss

Joan Dillon

Tzi Ma

Master Sheng

Alice Moran

Maya

Getenesh Berhe

Jordanna

Imali Perera

Dr. Gavde

James Adomian

Spider

Scott Thompson

Tiresias

Tim Robinson

Paranormal Investigator

Bobby Moynihan

Puffala (voice)

Dan Bakkedahl

Ruffala (voice)

Kathryn Greenwood

Picklepop (voice)

Zell Steele Morrow

Walter

Paul Campbell

Guy at Head of Table

Laura Miyata

Rachel

Masa Lizdek

Aja

Brittany Rae Robinson

Caterer

Bill Hader

Adolf Hitler

Xavier de Guzman

Xavier

Morgan David Jones

Waiter

Fred Armisen

Jesus, Tanaka (voice)

Joseph Cannata

Slick Looking Guy (uncredited)

Jim Chad

Strip Club Patron

Ian Deakin

Macarthur Member

Ali Hassan

Mr. Singh, Bodega Guy

Burl Moseley

Obama (voice)

James Preston Rogers

Bouncer

Vanessa Bayer

Laura Ferber

Michael Hogan

Military General

Louis Di Bianco

Father

Jeff Pangman

Charles Powell, Boss

Gideon Glick

Scientist

John Corbett

Older Advisor

Henry Kwok

Waiter

Rob deLeeuw

Violinist

Eddie Pepitone

Ashley Ross

Woman

Jess Salgueiro

DJ

Balford Gordon

Bar Security

Tina Jung

Katie

Adrian Rebucas

Kurt

Ephraim Ellis

Tim

Brandon Ludwig

Xander

Jeremy Ferdman

Zach

Jorma Taccone

Cupid

Oliver Becker

Zeus

Aurora Browne

Jessica

Jorge Molina

Doctor

Jim Armstrong

Husband

James Godfrey

Guy 1

Khalid Karim

Guy 2

Suresh John

Ravi

Eric Woolfe

Tanaka (Body)

Pascal Langdale

Roger

Nabil Rajo

Third Young Man

Miles Fisher

Graham

Brett Gelman

Demon

Jim Piddock

Rebecca Drysdale

Billy West

Stephen R. Hart

Cadaverous Ghoul

Jordan Claire Robbins

Julia

Rebecca Liddiard

Serving Ghoul

Matt Duncan

Ben

Shannon O'Neill

Judith

Claire Cavalheiro

Rachel

Carrie Brownstein

Ennis Esmer

Leo

Rob Baker

Tina

Jonathan Dubsky

Jeff

George Tchortov

Dying Bro

Stephen Chambers

Friend

Brendan Shoreman

Bro 1

Daneen Boone

Waitress

Jonathan Keltz

Dane

Marsha Mason

Audience Member #2

Alli Chung

Woman #1

Linnea Currie-Roberts

Woman #2

Alys Crocker

Female Friend

Chad Camilleri

Grim Reaper

Pat Mastroianni

Greg

Amish Patel

Computer Student

Ivan Sherry

Cult Member #1

Diane Johnstone

Cult Member #2

Johnie Chase

Choir Member #2

Dan Duran

Cable News Anchor, Anchorman, News Anchor, Political Anchor

Mark Andrada

Astronaut Alumn #1

Chris Gleason

Revival Tent Goer (uncredited)

Pasqualina Cardu

Reporter #3

Charlie Ebbs

Farmer #1

Jessica Rose

Katie

Tessa Bonhomme

Female Anchor

Andy Hull

Cop #1

Darryl Dinn

Rosa Fan #1

Michael Musi

Rosa Fan #2

Justin Mader

Male Anchor, Newscaster

Colin Doyle

Nerdy Guy #2

Jill Frappier

Female Judge

Natalie Moore

Backup Singer #2

Lisa Auguste

Backup Singer #3

Paul Johnston

Volunteer Search Crowd

Hannan Younis

Volunteer Search Crowd

Meghan Allen

Nurse

Hamza Fouad

Pedestrian #2

Dave Barclay

Old Time Reporter #1

Anthony Caputo

Wedding Patron

Jack Mosshammer

Border Patrol Agent

Julian Robino

Jimmy

Alejandro Ampudia

Hector, Hotdog Vendor

Jerry Rector

Jimmy's Dad

John Boylan

Dr. Hertzberg

Mike Petersen

Picklepop (Body) (uncredited)

Kevin McGarry

Owen Quest

Michael Benyaer

Khalid

Sophie Luborsky

Brick

Andy Yu

Chang

Jayden Greig

Gizmo (uncredited)

Drew Moss

Bouncer (uncredited)

Zack Pearlman

Angry Questioner from Tampa

John Billingsley

Watson

Jim Annan

Moderator

Daniel DeSanto

Mr. Martinez

Heidi Matijevic

Space Queen (uncredited)

Peter Gallagher

Joel Greenberg

Bruce McCulloch

Doctor

Gavin Fox

Logan

Toni Ellwand

Lawyer 1

Aniela Kurylo

Door Attendant

Alison Mackay

Stationary Store Employee

Francis Melling

Teenage Waiter

Rosalina Lee

Waitress (uncredited)

Kathy Maloney

Red Carpet Reporter

Marty Adams

Rumble

Adam Growe

Sports Reporter

Jeremy Crawford

Scuzz

Robin Duke

Patti

Mark McKinney

Tom

Jessica Lowe

Meghan

Cole Escola

Chris

Ramona Young

Robin

Mark Moses

Lucy's Dad

Julie White

Lucy's Mom

Richard Kind

God

Peter Nelson

Mark

Jacob Neayem

Doug

Ron Mustafaa

Nikhil

K. Trevor Wilson

Morris

Sean Jones

Patron (uncredited)

Peter Nelson

Mark